Publishing surgeons' performance remains controversial, British Medical Journal

Main Category: Public Health
Article Date: 20 Aug 2004 - 10:00 PDT

email to a friend   printer friendly   view / write opinions   rate article

Later this year, the performance of individual surgeons in the UK will be made publicly available, but the move remains controversial. Researchers in this week's BMJ discuss the issues in relation to cardiothoracic surgery.

The inquiry into cardiac deaths at Bristol Royal Infirmary recommended that patients must be able to obtain information on the performance of hospitals and individual surgeons. Since then, cardiothoracic surgeons have been voluntarily submitting figures for publication.

But the arguments for and against publication are finely balanced. Cardiac surgeons in the United States, where public reporting already exists, believe that the system is unfair, as the performance of a surgeon is highly dependent on his or her institution. It may also encourage surgeons to protect their results by avoiding high-risk patients.

The value of such publications also depends on whether the outcome usefully reflects quality of care, the ability to cater for differences in casemix, and whether the publication is designed to facilitate patient choice or show consistency of standards.

In the UK, surgeons have collected simple activity and mortality data for each surgeon for some years. The data is not detailed enough to cater for variations in casemix, so the surgeons have agreed for their results to be compared against statistically derived standards without compensation for casemix. Each surgeon will be measured to see whether or not they meet the agreed standard.

When these results are published later this year, medicine in the United Kingdom will have crossed a threshold into a new era, say the authors. This system is not perfect, but it is a first step towards transparent public accountability.

(The legacy of Bristol: public disclosure of individual surgeons' results)
http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/329/7463/450

Contacts:

Bruce Keogh, President Elect, Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland,
Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, UK
Email: Bruce.Keogh@uclh.org

James Roxburgh, Secretary, Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons of Great Britain and Ireland,
Royal College of Surgeons of England, London, UK
Email: James.Roxburgh@gstt.sthames.nhs.uk