Asthma Over Diagnosed In One Third Of Canadian Adults

Main Category: Respiratory / Asthma
Article Date: 18 Nov 2008 - 2:00 PST

email to a friend   printer friendly   view / write opinions   rate article

Asthma may be overdiagnosed in countries like Canada, suggests a longitudinal study of 540 obese and non-obese adults that found approximately one third of Canadians with physician-diagnosed asthma do not have asthma when objectively tested.

Asthma rates have increased in Canada and the US by 75% between 1980 and 1994, and studies suggest a possible link between obesity and asthma. In North America, obese adults are twice as likely to be diagnosed with asthma by a physician as non-obese adults. However, the "study found that 30% of adults recruited from the community who had been diagnosed with asthma by a physician had no evidence of asthma when their medications were tapered and when there were evaluated with serial assessments of symptoms, lung function and bronchial provocation tests," state Dr. Shawn Aaron from the Ottawa Health Research Institute and coauthors. "Overdiagnosis, or misdiagnosis, of asthma in Canada seems to be very common, but obese adults are not more likely to be overdiagnosed compared to normal weight adults."

Potential participants for the study were recruited by random telephone digit dialling from 8 Canadian cities and nearby rural areas from British Columbia to Nova Scotia, comprising a sample representative of the national population.

The researchers write that this overdiagnosis of asthma is concerning and suggest that physicians use spirometry, which measures the rate and volume of airflow through the lungs, for objective testing before labelling respiratory symptoms.

A related editorial by Dr. Matthew Stanbrook and Dr. Alan Kaplan and the CMAJ editorial team caution that asthma may be misdiagnosed rather than overdiagnosed. Symptoms attributed to asthma may signify other underlying medical conditions. They agree that all suspected cases of asthma must be diagnosed with spirometry and this should be available in all practice settings.

About CMAJ

CMAJ is the leading health sciences journal in Canada. CMAJ is a general medical journal publishing original research and review articles, commentaries and editorials, practice updates, an arts and ideas section and health news. Published continuously since 1911, new issues are uploaded on http://www.cmaj.ca every second Monday at 4:30 p.m. EST/EDT. http://www.cmaj.ca contains the complete editorial contents of CMAJ, supplemented by a variety of interactive features and additional content.

CMAJ is an open- and free-access journal - there are no author or page charges and access is provided free on the web (HighWire Press), http://www.cmaj.ca without registration. http://www.cmaj.ca has about 1 million requests and 250,000 page views per month. The Journal is part of the PubMed Central collection of journals http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov at the National Library of Medicine thus providing a guarantee of permanent archiving and open access. PubMed Central is now processing back issues of CMAJ to 1911. CMAJ's impact factor - a measure of the scientific importance of articles published - has more than tripled since 1997 and is now 7.1. The Journal receives about 2000 manuscripts a year (including letters to the editor and news articles). CMAJ's acceptance rate for unsolicited research and review articles is about 12%.

CMAJ