Doctors Refusal To Treat Obese Patients May Raise Legal Issues Smoking Provides Some Precedent, But It's Different, Says Expert
First, people who are obese may qualify for protection under the Americans With Disabilities Act [ADA], as well as under state statutes which prohibit discrimination based upon weight or personal appearance. In sharp contrast, smokers are not protected against this type of treatment under any statutes, says public interest law professor John Banzhaf, who pioneered the use of the ADA to protect nonsmokers from exposure to tobacco smoke in workplaces and public place.
Second, the federal government has officially classified obesity as a "health status" which is a protected category under certain health care statutes, and as a "disease" under others. On the other hand, the government has ruled that being a smoker is only a "behavior" entitled to no such protection. As one consequence, federal law permits charging smokers higher health insurance premiums without any limits, and even if the policy is not part of a wellness program meeting federal standards, whereas the same is not true for the obese.
Third, patients who need an operation can quit smoking in only a few days to qualify for the procedure, even if they return to smoking once they are discharged from the hospital. On the other hand, many obese patients cannot safely lose enough weight even over weeks or months, during which they could die or suffer other serious complications if the operation is not performed promptly
Fourth, many people still believe (correctly or not) that obesity is often caused by heredity, genes, childhood eating, and other factors over which adults have little if any control. On the other hand, most people see buying and using cigarettes as a habit or a choice, making it easier to justify a medical exclusion policy for the small percentage of Americans who still smoke.
Fifth, although there is evidence that for many people smoking involves addiction, that addiction is to the drug nicotine, not to the act of smoking itself, which is a behavior. Because those who desire to quit smoking (e.g., for a medical procedure) can ingest nicotine from nicotine gum, nicotine patches, nicotine spray, nicotine inhalers, and e-cigarettes, their decision to ingest it by smoking rather than by using nicotine replacement products is a choice. Since it is a choice rather than an addiction, disease, or health status, it seems more legally justified to restrict access to medical care to smokers than to the obese.
George Washington University Law School
There are no references listed for this article.
Please use one of the following formats to cite this article in your essay, paper or report:
George Washington University Law School. "Doctors Refusal To Treat Obese Patients May Raise Legal Issues Smoking Provides Some Precedent, But It's Different, Says Expert." Medical News Today. MediLexicon, Intl., 18 May. 2011. Web.
22 Mar. 2017. <http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases/225667.php>
George Washington University Law School. (2011, May 18). "Doctors Refusal To Treat Obese Patients May Raise Legal Issues Smoking Provides Some Precedent, But It's Different, Says Expert." Medical News Today. Retrieved from
Please note: If no author information is provided, the source is cited instead.
Contact our news editors
For any corrections of factual information, or to contact our editorial team, please see our contact page.
Copyright Medical News Today: Excluding email/sharing services explicitly offered on this website, material published on Medical News Today may not be reproduced, or distributed without the prior written permission of Medilexicon International Ltd. Please contact us for further details.