Creating a free account will enable you to subscribe to our daily and weekly email newsletters, as well as customize your reading experience to show only the categories most relevant to you.
Signing up only take a few minutes, so why not give it a try and see what you've been missing out on.
Individuals have a right to participate in risky research trials, which might harm their health or even kill them, and institutional review boards (known as research ethics committees in the UK) - which are responsible for deciding whether a particular research trial can take place in a given institution - are potentially impeding the progress of research by rejecting such studies on ethical grounds, according to a Viewpoint published in The Lancet on Wednesday 18 September.
Dr David Shaw, of the Institute for Biomedical Ethics, at the University of Basel, Switzerland, argues that "Institutional review boards should never reject a study because it poses too high a risk to participants, and that their role should be confined to ensuring that risks and any potential benefits are fully explained to potential participants. Everyone should have the right to participate in research without paternalistic decisions about risk being made on their behalf."
It has been argued that patients who participate in trials - particularly those who are terminally ill - are often under what is termed "the therapeutic misconception", whereby they wrongly believe that they will benefit from participation in a study, even if they are told they might not. Ethics committees frequently deny approval for trials where patients are seen as unlikely to benefit from treatment offered during the trial.
However, Dr Shaw argues that instead of this overly paternalistic approach, institutional review boards should instead ensure that trial participants fully understand the risks involved, and if they still want to take part, they should not be prevented from doing so. Furthermore, he suggests that relaxing attitudes towards patient participation in risky research could greatly benefit some research programmes, particularly for novel drugs where, in the early stages of development, trials are often difficult or impossible to approve, because of uncertainty about prospective harm or benefit.
"Why potential participants should be denied the opportunity to participate in trials that pose even higher risks if they wish to do so, is unclear," says Dr Shaw. "Competent adults can, for example, go skydiving, potholing, or bungee jumping. All of these sports are highly dangerous and, unlike research, confer no benefit to society. For example, skydivers have a one in 100 000 risk of death at each jump, and the injury rate is about one in 200. Almost half of bungee jumpers sustain at least minor injury. Why should people not be allowed to run similar or higher risks by participating in societally beneficial clinical research? Although a lot less fun, and also potentially fatal, participation in such research has the potential to help people and demonstrates solidarity with one's community."
"To stop people participating in high-risk research denies them the right to help their communities, patients worldwide, and future generations of patients...Assisted dying is increasingly regarded as acceptable in many developed countries; if healthy people are allowed to participate in high-risk sports that might kill them, and sick people can be assisted in ending their lives, why should both groups not be able to risk dying in a way that potentially benefits society?"
The Lancet - Published Online September 18, 2013 DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(13)61575-5
Author: David Shaw
Article adapted by Medical News Today from original press release. Click 'references' tab above for source.
Visit our Clinical Trials / Drug Trials category page for the latest news on this subject.
Please use one of the following formats to cite this article in your essay, paper or report:
Lancet, The. "Patients have a right to participate in risky research." Medical News Today. MediLexicon, Intl., 18 Sep. 2013. Web.
8 Dec. 2013. <http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases/266174>
Lancet, T. (2013, September 18). "Patients have a right to participate in risky research." Medical News Today. Retrieved from
Please note: If no author information is provided, the source is cited instead.
If you write about specific medications, operations, or procedures please do not name healthcare professionals by name.
For any corrections of factual information, or to contact the our editorial team, please use our feedback form. Please send any medical news or health news press releases to:
Note: Any medical information published on this website is not intended as a substitute for informed medical advice and you should not take any action before consulting with a health care professional. For more information, please read our terms and conditions.
This page was printed from: http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases/266174.php
Visit www.medicalnewstoday.com for medical news and health news headlines posted throughout the day, every day.
© 2004-2013 All rights reserved. MNT (logo) is the registered trade mark of MediLexicon International Limited.