We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.
Medical News Today only shows you brands and products that we stand behind.Our team thoroughly researches and evaluates the recommendations we make on our site. To establish that the product manufacturers addressed safety and efficacy standards, we:
- Evaluate ingredients and composition: Do they have the potential to cause harm?
- Fact-check all health claims: Do they align with the current body of scientific evidence?
- Assess the brand: Does it operate with integrity and adhere to industry best practices?
Lull and Casper are two mattress companies who sell their products directly to consumers rather than going through third party retailers.
Each company offers a foam mattress, and Casper has expanded its line to include hybrid mattresses, too.
However, because their prices and offerings are similar, consumers may have difficulty deciding whether a Lull or Casper product is right for them.
No mattress is perfect for everyone, so here are some things that a person may wish to consider when making a decision.
Both companies aim to make mattresses more accessible to consumers who are unable to go to a physical store.
Some things to consider about each brand’s reputation include the following:
- Online reviews: Both companies generally earn high reviews. On the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website, each has an A+ designation, indicating that they follow the BBB’s policies for responding to negative reviews. Casper have more reviews overall and therefore more negative reviews.
- Controversies: In 2016, Casper sued several mattress bloggers for negative reviews. They claimed that the bloggers unfairly directed business to their competitors. After settling the suits, Casper gave another company money to buy one of the bloggers’ websites. Lull, on the other hand, have not been involved in any high profile controversies.
- Approach to negative reviews: Lull promise not to hide any negative reviews and allow users to search for negative reviews on their site. Casper also allow users to sort to find negative reviews. However, their approach to negative feedback has been aggressive and has included suing certain mattress bloggers.
- Safety and sustainability: Both brands’ mattresses have earned the CertiPUR-US designation for their foam, indicating that their mattresses are free of many harmful chemicals. Both use a fire retardant sock rather than flame retardant chemicals. Lull and Casper both claim that they have a commitment to sustainable, environmentally friendly practices.
- Trial and warranty: Casper and Lull each offer 10-year limited warranties, as well as a 100-night in-home trial. They both have some negative reviews regarding how they handle their warranties, but most reviewers give the companies high ratings for overall customer service.
- Variety: Casper offer four mattresses, so buyers can choose the firmness and support that is right for them. Lull only offer one mattress at the moment.
Please note that the writer of this article has not tried any of these products. All information presented is purely research-based.
Casper Original Mattress
This mattress is a foam bed. Its outer layer is breathable, perforated foam for a cooler sleep.
An inner layer of contouring foam offers pressure relief, while the base layer of thicker foam offers support and prevents sagging.
The original hybrid option uses the same structure as the original foam but includes a layer of individually wrapped coils instead of the base layer of foam. This offers additional support and a slightly firmer sleep surface.
Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress
This mattress offers Casper’s highest level of support in a medium firm mattress, which may make it a suitable choice for people with chronic pain.
It features an outer layer of cooling gel, three layers of supportive foam, and individually wrapped coils for additional support.
This mattress also contains supportive gel pods under the lower back and waist areas to reduce pressure.
Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress
This mattress offers a plush top layer, two layers of foam, and a base layer of individually wrapped coils.
The top layer of foam also contains tiny perforations to promote air circulation and help people stay cool during sleep.
Reviewers say that this mattress offers medium firmness.
Lull offer just a single mattress, but they say that they designed it with numerous sleep styles and needs in mind.
The mattress uses memory foam to contour to the body and reduce pressure points. It also comes with a plush top cover for a soft feel.
The mattress contains three layers of support:
- The top layer is a cooling gel foam that helps prevent overheating.
- The next layer of resilient foam prevents motion transfer and conforms to the body.
- The thick base layer offers more support and prevents the mattress from sagging.
Lull’s mattress adapts to the shape of a person’s body. Reviewers note that it sleeps well in many different positions. They generally agree that it is a medium to medium firm mattress with a high level of support.
Some factors to consider when shopping for a mattress include the following:
- Thickness: The thickness of the material, especially in foam mattresses, can increase support and reduce pressure.
- Material: The material from which the mattress is made may affect how supportive and comfortable it is. Some people prefer softer memory foam mattresses, while others want a firmer hybrid or traditional spring mattress.
- Durability: Mattresses that use springs for support are typically more durable when there are more springs per surface area.
- Warranty and trial period: Casper and Lull offer identical warranties and trial periods. Also, consider what reviewers have said about how good the companies are at honoring these commitments.
- Reputation: Look for negative news stories, reviews on third party websites, recalls, and any history of lawsuits.
- Value: Rather than looking solely at price, consider the total value the mattress offers. For example, a highly durable but more expensive mattress may actually save a person money if they can use it for longer.
There is no conclusive scientific evidence proving that a specific type of mattress is better for health. In fact, one 2016 systematic review emphasizes that the term “orthopedic mattress” is a marketing phrase, not a medical term.
However, some studies suggest that mattress firmness may affect pain. A 2003 study, for example, compared medium firm to firm mattresses and found that the medium firm mattress offered greater pain relief after 90 days.
Although it is unclear which specific type of mattress is best for each user, one thing is certain: sleep quality affects health. For example,
People who do not sleep well on their current mattress may wish to experiment with different mattress options until they find a good fit. The 100-day trials that Casper and Lull offer make it easier to test a mattress’s real-world effects.
Both Casper and Lull offer foam mattresses, though Casper’s lineup is broader, which may address more needs.
Potential buyers should take advantage of the in-home free trials to ensure that they choose the right mattress for them.
People with chronic medical conditions may wish to ask a doctor for input and read reviews from people with similar conditions before making a purchase.