Multislice CT Scans Effective In Detection Of Pulmonary Embolisms Without Ultrasonography

Editor's Choice
Main Category: Vascular
Also Included In: Medical Devices / Diagnostics;  MRI / PET / Ultrasound
Article Date: 23 Apr 2008 - 0:00 PDT

email to a friend   printer friendly   view / write opinions

In detecting pulmonary embolisms (PE), it is just as effective to use D-dimer measurement in combination with multislice CT scan (MSCT) as opposed to D-dimer venous ultrasonography of the leg and MSCT. This means that venous ultrasonography may no longer be needed to diagnose PE when MSCT is used, according to the authors of an Article released on April 18, 2008 in The Lancet.

Pulmonary embolisms are blood clot blockages of the pulmonary artery. To create this, a venous clot may form and detatch from its point of attachment, flowing into the arterial system. Detection of PE presently includes clinical probability assessment (CPA) with subsequent sequential diagnostic tests, such as the D-dimer, ultrasonography, and CT scans.

A CT chest scan uses composite x-rays to form a three dimensional picture. Chest CT scans are considered a promising new method to visualize pulmonary clots, but the 'single slice' CT has a low sensitivity for detecting PE (about 70%,) which limits its possibilities as an independent test. In contrast, an MSCT is able to make several images in a similar way simultaneously. MSCT has provided new potential to replace pulmonary angiography, because it allows more accurate visualization of the segmental and subsegmental vessels. D-dimer ultrasonography involves detection of a protein present in the blood after a blood clot forms.

To investigate the relative accuracy of these diagnostic techniques, Dr Marc Righini, of the Geneva University Hospital and Faculty of Medicine, Switzerland, and colleagues, performed a randomized controlled trial of 1,819 outpatients who were clinically suspected of having PE. They compared two strategies for diagnosis: the first (DD-CT), with 903 patients, evaluated CPA combined with D-Dimer measurement and MSCT; the second (DD-CT-US), with 916 patients, was the same but included venous ultrasonography of the leg. The effectiveness was quantified by calculating the 3-month risk of recurrent deep vein thrombosis or PE in patients who were left untreated because they had been excluded by either strategy.

The prevalence of PE was 20.6% in both groups. There were 186 in the DD-CT group and 189 in the DD-CT-US group. After these patients were removed from the population, 838 remained DD-CT and 855 DD-US-CT. Later examination showed taht the 3-month risk of PE was 0.3% in both groups -- that is, that both strategies were equally effective. Compared to the old method, which requires lung scans with nuclear medicine techniques, MSCT would be easier and more widely available to doctors.

The authors finally say that ultrasound is not completely necessary in the diagnosis of PE. "We conclude that ultrasound is not needed to rule out pulmonary embolism when MSCT is used. An ultrasound could be of use in patients with a contraindication to CT."

Professor Paul Kyrle and Professor Sabine Eichinger, Medical University of Vienna contributed a comment in which they said: "This approach will facilitate the diagnostic work-up of patients with suspected pulmonary embolism and seems to be cost-effective." They additionally discuss new treatments for PE, including phase III clinical trials.

Diagnosis of pulmonary embolism by multidetector CT alone or combined with venous ultrasonography of the leg: a randomised non-inferiority trial
Marc Righini, Gregoire Le Gal, Drahomir Aujesky, Pierre-Marie Roy, Olivier Sanchez, Franck Verschuren, Olivier Rutschmann, Michel Nonent, Jacques Cornuz, Frederic Thys, Cedric Petit Le Manach, Marie-Pierre Revel, Pierre-Alexandre Poletti, Guy Meyer, Dominique Mottier, Thomas Perneger, Henri Bounameaux, Arnaud Perrier
Lancet 2008; 371: 1343-52
Click Here For Summary
Click Here For Related Podcast

Written by Anna Sophia McKenney
Copyright: Medical News Today
Not to be reproduced without permission of Medical News Today