An analysis that reviews studies covering over two million people finds shift work is associated with a higher risk for vascular events, such as heart attack and ischemic stroke. The study is the largest examination of shift work and vascular risk to date.
The researchers, from Canada and Norway, write about their findings in a paper published online in the BMJ on Thursday.
Night shift workers had the highest risk for coronary events (41%).
However, shift work was not linked to a higher risk of death (from any cause).
Scientists have known for a while that shift work upsets the body’s natural body clock (circadian rhythm) and work-life balance, and a number of studies have linked it to health problems, such as increased risk of high blood pressure and high cholesterol.
And the link with cancer has already made a mark in the politics of occupational health since 38 Danish female night shift workers in 2008 were compensated after their breast cancer was officially recognized as an occupational illness.
But, the link between shift work and vascular disease is controversial. The authors propose one reason could be the varying methods, populations and definitions of shift work and coronary events that previous studies have used.
They also suggest previous analyses are now outdated: they “did not use validated tools for assessing studies, did not capture all available data, and did not apply quantitative techniques to compute summary risk estimates,” they write.
For their study, the international team, led by Daniel G Hackam, associate professor in the Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics at Western University in Canada, pooled and analyzed the results of 34 studies covering 2,011,935 people and compared shift workers to regular daytime workers or the general population.
They defined shift working as working patterns that differed from regular daytime working (9 am to 5 pm), including evening shifts, irregular or unspecified shifts, mixed schedules, night shifts and rotating shifts.
Of the more than 2 million participants, 17,357 experienced some kind of coronary event, 6,598 had heart attacks (myocardial infarction), and 1,854 had ischaemic strokes. An ischaemic stroke is caused by a lack of blood supply in the brain.
The analysis showed all these vascular events were significantly more common among shift workers than other people.
The researchers found that:
“Shift work was associated with myocardial infarction (risk ratio 1.23, 95% confidence interval 1.15 to 1.31; I2=0) and ischaemic stroke (1.05, 1.01 to 1.09; I2=0). Coronary events were also increased (risk ratio 1.24, 1.10 to 1.39), albeit with significant heterogeneity across studies (I2=85%).”
By “significant heterogeneity” the researchers refer to the fact that there was a certain lack of consistency in research methods, assumptions, sampling criteria and definitions across the 34 studies they analyzed.
When they examined the possible sources of this lack of consistency in study methods, they found that “presence or absence of adjustment for smoking and socioeconomic status” was not one of them.
They also found that although the risk for vascular events was higher among shift workers, the results show they were at no higher risk of death from any cause.
The researchers say that although the relative risks they calculated are modest, because of the high frequency of shift work in the general population, the implications for public health are not insignificant.
For instance, if you applied these risks to Canada, where during 2008-09, nearly a third of workers were on shifts, then 7% of heart attacks, 7.3% of all coronary events, and 1.6% of ischaemic strokes could be due to shift working.
The findings should impact public policy and occupational medicine, say the researchers.
For example, shift workers could be educated about how to spot early signs of heart problems, and screening programmes could help identify and treat risk factors like high blood pressure and cholesterol in shift workers.
The researchers call for further studies to find out which groups of shift workers are likely to be the most affected by these findings, and how overall vascular health is affected by changes in shift patterns.
Written by Catharine Paddock PhD