A new study of older women living in Australia finds that eating more vegetables — especially cruciferous vegetables, such as broccoli, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, and cauliflower — might help to prevent clogged arteries, or atherosclerosis, a main cause of heart attack and stroke.
“This is one of only a few studies,” explains lead study author Lauren Blekkenhorst, currently at the University of Western Australia in Perth, “that have explored the potential impact of different types of vegetables on measures of subclinical atherosclerosis, the underlying cause of cardiovascular disease.”
In a paper that is now published in the Journal of the American Heart Association, she and her colleagues suggest that, should their findings be confirmed in further studies, guidelines on how to eat healthfully should emphasize that a diet rich in cruciferous vegetables may protect against vascular disease.
Such vegetables include arugula, cabbage, cauliflower, broccoli, Brussels sprouts, kale, horseradish, turnips, radish, watercress, collard greens, and others.
Cruciferous vegetables are rich sources of: fiber; vitamins C, E, and K; several carotenoids; folate; and minerals. They also contain sulfur compounds known as glucosinolates, which account for their somewhat bitter taste and pungent smell; glucosinolates and are also thought to be important for generating the associated health benefits.
When we cook and eat cruciferous vegetables, the glucosinolates contained within them break down into biologically active compounds, such as nitriles, indoles, isothiocyanates, and thiocyanates.
Evidence from both cell and animal studies
In their study paper, Blekkenhorst and team note that research consistently shows evidence of a link between a higher consumption of vegetables and a reduced risk of heart disease and stroke.
They explain how measuring the thickness of the walls of carotid arteries in the neck can help to assess the risk of heart attack and stroke, because it is a reliable indicator of atherosclerosis, the “underlying cause of these cardiovascular diseases.”
Atherosclerosis is a
Over time, the plaque buildup causes the arteries to narrow and harden, which, in turn, restricts the flow of blood carrying oxygen and nutrients to organs and tissues.
Eventually, blood flow can become so restricted that it leads to heart attack, stroke, and sometimes even death.
The authors discuss how the Mediterranean diet, the vegetarian diet, and other diets that have high vegetable intakes have been linked to less thickening of the carotid artery wall.
“However,” they add, “the role of individual dietary components, such as vegetables, is uncertain.” In addition, they note that there has been little investigation of links between “specific types of vegetables” and “reduction in atherosclerosis.”
That is why, for their study — in which they examined the links between vegetable intake and carotid artery measures of atherosclerosis — Blekkenhorst and her colleagues also examined links with types of vegetable.
They analyzed data on 954 women living in Australia who were aged 70 or older in 1998, which was when they filled in detailed questionnaires about their food intake.
Among other things, these questionnaires asked about the frequency of vegetable consumption, on a 10-point scale that ranged from “never” to “three times or more per day.”
The women also noted, from a choice of 24 types, which vegetables they ate, such as: yellow, orange, and red; legumes; leafy greens; cruciferous vegetables; and alliums such as onions, shallots, garlic, and leeks.
In 2001, all the women underwent sonogram exams that measured the thickness of their carotid artery walls and assessed severity of plaque buildup.
The results showed that the women who consumed the most vegetables had, on average, carotid artery walls that were 0.05 millimeters thinner than women who consumed the fewest vegetables.
Blekkenhorst explains that this difference is “likely significant, because a 0.1-millimeter decrease in carotid wall thickness is associated with a 10 percent to 18 percent decrease in risk of stroke and heart attack.”
She and her team also found that for every 10 extra grams of cruciferous vegetables consumed per day, there was a 0.8 percent reduction in average thickness of carotid artery wall. No such link was found for other types of vegetable.
“After adjusting for lifestyle, cardiovascular disease risk factors (including medication use) as well as other vegetable types and dietary factors,” says Blekkenhorst, “our results continued to show a protective association between cruciferous vegetables and carotid artery wall thickness.”
It is important to note that, because of limitations of the study design, the results do not prove that eating more cruciferous vegetables prevents or reduces thickening of artery walls. However, neither do they contradict the idea.
“Still, dietary guidelines should highlight the importance of increasing consumption of cruciferous vegetables for protection from vascular disease.”