Eczema is a general term for conditions that cause skin irritation or inflammation. It includes atopic dermatitis and contact dermatitis, which are often confused due to their similar-looking symptoms. However, the two conditions have different causes and treatment plans.
While atopic dermatitis and contact dermatitis fall under the umbrella term eczema and present with similar symptoms, they have different causes. Typically, a person inherits atopic dermatitis, while contact dermatitis occurs following exposure to an external factor that triggers a reaction.
This article discusses the two conditions, their differences and how to tell them apart, alongside symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment options.
It is a chronic skin condition that comes and goes throughout an individual’s life. Eczema runs in families and often occurs in people with a family or personal history of asthma and hay fever. AD usually begins in childhood, affecting 15–20% of children, and may continue to affect 1–3% of the adult population worldwide.
Contact dermatitis (CD) is also a skin condition where a person develops skin redness, inflammation, and other lesions after coming into contact with an irritant or allergen that triggers an allergic reaction. It is also fairly common, accounting for
There are two types of contact dermatitis: allergic (ACD) and irritant contact dermatitis (ICD). ACD refers to a person experiencing an allergic reaction following skin contact with an allergen, while ICD results from an external factor that damages a person’s skin.
There are several differences between AD and CD. These include:
AD is a chronic condition due to a
In contrast, CD is not normally hereditary nor a chronic condition — it does not usually relate to other allergic conditions, such as hay fever or asthma. However, some people with atopic tendencies may be
In CD, skin reactions only occur upon exposure to an irritant or allergen. A person’s skin condition usually improves or clears upon the identification, removal, and avoidance of the cause.
AD usually presents early in life, affecting around 60% of children during their first year. On the other hand, all individuals are at risk of developing CD, but it occurs more in adults than children.
In AD, allergens and infections trigger higher immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibody levels in the person’s blood. In contrast, while there is also an immune system involvement in ACD, it is due to a type of immune cell called
Both conditions present with skin lesions, making it difficult to differentiate the two based on the type of rashes alone.
However, the location of the rashes may help differentiate the two conditions. AD lesions have a typical distribution based on age. In infants and toddlers, the rash typically appears on the face and extensor surfaces, such as the back of their elbows and feet. In children and adolescents, it usually occurs in flexural areas, such as the back of their knees, front of the elbows, front of the ankles, and the skin creases in the neck.
In contrast, CD rashes can occur on any part of a person’s body that encounters an irritant or allergen. However, lesions often affect a person’s face, hands, and neck. Skin lesions in CD, especially in the irritant type, often have visible borders.
According to the National Eczema Association, a person may have both AD and CD. This is because they have different triggers.
A 2019 study mentions a multifaceted relationship between the two conditions, and a 2018 article adds that ICD can co-exist with both AD and ACD. Additionally, a 2018 review suggests that people with AD have abnormal immune system processes, disrupted skin barriers, and frequently use topical medications and emollients, predisposing them to develop ACD.
Evidence suggests an association between AD and a mutation in the FLG gene, which produces a protein called filaggrin. This protein plays a role in skin hydration, and research suggests that a shortage of filaggrin can impair the skin’s barrier function, which may contribute to the development of AD.
Exposure to environmental triggers, such as changes in temperature, skin irritants, and allergens, may also cause flare-ups in people with AD. In CD, people develop skin lesions after exposure to an irritant or allergen. Many different allergens can trigger both types of dermatitis. Examples include:
|Atopic dermatitis causes||Contact dermatitis causes|
|Family history of eczema||Soaps|
|Personal history of eczema||Detergents|
|Hay fever||Hair dyes|
|Food allergies||Citrus fruit|
|Sweat||Poison ivy, poison oak, and poison sumac|
|Long, hot baths or showers||Shampoo|
|Frequent exposure to chemicals at work|
AC and CD have similar symptoms, and both typically undergo the 3 stages of eczema: acute, subacute, and chronic. Both conditions present with discoloration, itching, and skin lesions such as cracked weeping skin, plaques, and small blisters in the acute phase. While both are itchy, CD is more likely to result in stinging, burning, and painful sensations.
A doctor diagnoses a person with AD based on the condition’s persistent history, the skin lesion’s features, appearance, distribution, and other associated signs. According to the American Academy of Dermatology, essential features should be present. These include:
- typical appearance and age-specific patterns
- chronic or relapsing history
A family or personal history of atopy, having the disorder at a young age, and dry skin are symptoms present in most cases and support a person’s AD diagnosis.
A health practitioner can typically diagnose CD following a physical examination and the appearance of the skin. To help identify the allergen or irritant, they will ask about a person’s family history, occupation, lifestyle, and medication use. They may also suggest a patch test to check a person’s reaction against known allergens.
The goal for both conditions are similar — management involves avoiding triggers and irritants. However, management for CD is more straightforward than AD. Since AD is lifelong, doctors usually create an individualized plan to manage a person’s condition.
Over-the-counter products, such as antihistamines, pain relievers, or topical hydrocortisone, can help relieve mild symptoms. Doctors may also prescribe topical medications to treat small areas. However, if the skin lesion is severe or covers a large area, doctors may prescribe a short course of oral medications.
Other treatments for AD may include:
- proper bathing and moisturizing
- wet wraps
- biologic drugs
- complementary therapies, such as meditation or yoga
Skin lesions from CD usually clear up and do not usually become a cause for concern. However, individuals should see their doctors if their rashes do not go away, become widespread, or become very uncomfortable or painful.
Similarly, people with AD should check with their doctors if:
- symptoms worsen
- it disturbs their sleep and daily activities
- the time between flare-ups shortens
- new lesions appear or affect new areas
Atopic dermatitis and contact dermatitis are two common types of eczema that are often confused. While they are both inflammatory skin conditions that share similar symptoms, their causes are different. Atopic dermatitis is an internal skin condition, whereas contact dermatitis results from external factors.
Proper diagnosis is important to ensure that individuals receive the appropriate treatment to help clear the skin and manage the condition.