- Antidepressants are often one of the first lines of treatment for depression but they can have side effects or not work for many people.
- Research has been trying to establish if altering one’s diet might have some effect in countering depressive symptoms.
- New findings suggest that some people with high levels of the amino acid proline in their diet may experience more severe depression, but this is largely dependent on a person’s microbiome.
Some research has suggested that diet may have an impact on depression. A diet
Now, a study, published in
The research also indicates that a person’s gut bacteria may affect how that amino acid is processed, and how it can counter its depressive effects in some people.
First, they analyzed the type and amount of amino acids in the diets of those participating in the study. They also analyzed blood plasma and fecal samples from the participants.
Those who had a higher level of proline in their diet reported more severe depression.
The participants who reported more severe depression also tended to have higher levels of plasma proline, suggesting that the proline in their diet was not being metabolised effectively.
What is proline?
Amino acids are the building blocks of proteins. There are two types: essential amino acids, which must be consumed through the diet, and non-essential amino acids which are found in food but are also synthesized in the body.
Proline is a non-essential amino acid. It is used to make collagen, the protein that forms connective fibers in our skin, bones, and muscles. It is mainly found in animal-derived foods that are rich in collagen. These include:
A plant-based diet will contain lower levels of proline, but vegans can get the amino acid from dietary supplements or from some vegetables, including:
Some people with high proline intake did not report worse symptoms. The researchers found that these people had lower levels of plasma proline.
On analyzing their gut bacteria, they found that their microbiota was similar to that of participants reporting low levels of depression.
The gut bacteria in those with high proline intake and low levels of depression contained species involved in transport and metabolism of proline.
“Without a doubt, the microbiome affects levels of proline, but what levels and how this affects mood/depression or other aspects of the body are to be determined.”
— Dr. John Tsai, board certified gastroenterologist at Austin Gastroenterology
To test their theory, the researchers transplanted fecal samples from participants in the study into mice. The mice that received microbiota from more depressed participants with high proline levels showed behaviors associated with depression.
To further test the effect of proline, the researchers isolated the gut bacteria they thought might be making the difference.
They found higher levels of Bifidobacterium in participants with fewer depressive symptoms along with some strains of Lactobacillus. Another gut bacterium,
They gave food containing Lactobacillus or Enterobacter to fruit flies (Drosophila melanogaster). The flies given the Lactobacillus were much more motivated to eat and climb than those given the Enterobacter.
In their final experiment, the researchers genetically modified the flies so that proline could not be transported to the brain — these flies proved highly resilient to depression.
Dr. Tsai, however, said he was not convinced by the study’s conclusions.
“I feel this study is interesting but has many limitations in study design as well as extrapolating mice/fly results to humans. There may be a correlation but this study far from proves causation,” he pointed out.
“I think the most interesting aspect of this study came from the fruit flies and how proline channels in their brains adapted. Using proline or proline-rich/depleted foods in humans and functional PET scanning of the brain (specifically the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus) may be a very interesting study to consider,” he added.
The researchers suggest that diets with reduced proline content may be effective in reducing depressive symptoms.
Alternatively, they suggest that adjusting the microbiome to contain higher levels of the bacteria that metabolize proline, thereby reducing the amounts reaching the blood plasma may be a route to treating depression without modifying the diet.
“I don’t think there is enough here to directly link dietary proline levels with depression based upon this study. It is worth investigating more diligently with a human experiment that is randomized, controlled, prospective and double-blinded,” Dr. Tsai concluded.